The Problem of Polaris



According to the flat earth model, Polaris, the North Pole star, should be visible from the southern latitudes. Polaris is directly over the north pole.

In the diagram below, you can see that Polaris should clearly be visible. One cannot argue that the light from Polaris cannot reach the southern hemisphere, because light from the morning sunrise travels the same distance o the flat earth model.

The North Pole to Sydney is about 12,000km. The altitude (the angle above the horizon) of Polaris, prediced by the flat earth model, does not align with reality. Distance are almost never used in flat earth models and so one has to estimate the height of Polaris. Given that some say that it is below the dome and some say it is above the dome, then the following approximations would suffice:
  • If Polaris were 6,000km above the earth then it's altitude when seen from Sydney should be 30 degrees.
  • If Polaris were 12,000km above the earth then it's altitude when seen from Sydney should be 45 degrees.v
  • If Polaris were 18,000km above the earth then it's altitude when seen from Sydney should be 60 degrees.
The reality is that as an observer travels away from the north pole the altitude of Polaris falls.
  • The altitude at the north pole is 90 degrees.
  • At a latitude of 60 deg north the altitude is 60 degrees
  • At a latitude of 30 deg north the altitude is 30 degrees
  • At a latitude of 0 deg north the altitude is 0 degrees. This meas the Polaris is at the level of the horizon.
Beyond the equator it is no longer visible. This is in keeping with a spherical model of the earth where
  • Polaris is a long way away
  • The curvature of the earth prevents it from being seen from the southern hemisphere.

It is clear that the flat earth model fails to explain what is seen in the skies with regards to Polaris.

Those in the northern hemisphere cannot see the Southern Cross, a constellation in the south of our skies, because of the curvature of the earth, for the same reason.